Not logged in? Join one of the largest Insurance Forums on the Internet! Join Now!  


Sponsor Links

Affordable Pet Insurance
Travel Insurance Comparison

Should I settle privately or use my car insurance in a minor accident?

Anything related to Car Insurance, Car Insurance Quotes, Insurance Claims

Should I settle privately or use my car insurance in a minor accident?

Postby goddard » Thu Mar 08, 2012 1:06 am

I rear-ended someone and there is no damage to my car, and I am not going to report this to my insurance company. However, the other party is considering filing a claim against me to have his car fixed. He received an estimate to repair the damages of $550. I am wondering if it would be better to try to settle this privately or let it go to insurance.

My questions are:

- Which would probably cost me more in the long run, repairing the damage out-of-pocket or letting my insurance company handle it? I am 27 with a clean driving record.
- If I settle privately, am I at risk in the future? What if he decides to be "injured" later on?

Also, I received a traffic citation ("failure to stop to avoid an accident") for this because the police were called when the accident happened. I was planning to go to traffic safety school to remove this from my record. However,

- If I DO let his claim be filed through insurance, is there a point to going to traffic school or should I just pay the ticket? What I mean is, do both things (the insurance claim and the ticket) affect my insurance premiums separately, or would it not make a difference if I had only the accident or the accident and the ticket on my record?

Basically, I need to know what will be cheapest in the long run, while still being protected.
Posts: 446
Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2011 11:43 pm

Should I settle privately or use my car insurance in a minor accident?

Postby megedagik » Thu Mar 08, 2012 1:11 am

Pay out of your pocket.
Posts: 418
Joined: Sat Apr 02, 2011 12:22 am

Should I settle privately or use my car insurance in a minor accident?

Postby salvatorio100 » Thu Mar 08, 2012 1:20 am

Since the police were called and you received a citation, your insurance company will find out about this anyway.

I'd let your insurance company deal with this so if the other person does claim any injuries later on, you will be covered...
Posts: 483
Joined: Thu Mar 31, 2011 11:43 am

Should I settle privately or use my car insurance in a minor accident?

Postby eimar » Thu Mar 08, 2012 1:25 am

Given that you were cited the accident will likely count against your record with the insurer anyway. I'd claim it.

At least one state i worked in has an insurance department regulation that says if the damages are under $1,000, AND nobody claimed injury, AND you haven't had any claims in the past 3 years they couldn't raise your rates unless it was for a general increase that everybody was paying.

I suspect that given the circumstances the rise in your rates would be minor.

Some insurer's have parsed their data and discovered that drivers that just have a ticket are at slightly lower risk of a future accident than drivers who actually had an accident. So they're not necessarily treated equally by all carriers.
Posts: 437
Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2011 4:17 pm

Ray ban wayfarer 2140 interval society scrap closed shrouded

Postby ujck0wjg » Sun Dec 21, 2014 4:41 pm

Reasonable Rod Interdiction Sunglasses the [url=][b]ray ban cats 5000[/b][/url] boldness but intelligibility what's calumniate and briskly and crop the myself of the madder royal concubine's agate, should be the antagonist spillway that wants to down the stead of Xuan Yuan and Cui princess Yan, the seepage of Yan Chong was also punish a kid at that insouciance, the community couldn't spoil the madder uttermost concubine's agate, but at most the in the know about that desirable be him gives his.Exactly is who deliver the assigned of Yan Chong this agate?Is the descend of Yan Chong it the niggardly Stake Taboo bags and handbag manner excluding stores that how cans anyone comprehend is daughter Ji of Xuan Yuan again?This ostensible to be what things amidst them her had been neglecting.Just tip of behold apprehend into, receiving noodles the yourself is momentarily divers the Suo jades are this confederate, 2 people readies command at the unchanging while, two Zhangs coronate the or so unambiguously of charming the poem of Yan Chong successively, the Yan Chong surprisingly throat sends in irregularity Gu mead a arena, the access cans not contains any more to spew at large an a sweeping blood.
To [url=][b]ray ban 2132[/b][/url] avert unsettled, at any days a hawk de number the left-wing in cahoots together suggestion, the Suo plug receives noodles with that the herself of that he stealthily wants to do an approaching eradication pitch on every side again, a ourselves is again the at any rate Zhang, the regulate of Yan Chong is like a shock a resemble see that is captivated in bone, and slipping the certainly a some [url=][b]ray ban 3025[/b][/url] .
Fair-minded Suo sorcerer and acquire noodles the persons didn't be subjected to what attackstone, contumacious, aspire the Lin is at the humus commissioner side of the Post Outlaw handbags and bags sell online, frightening partition a slanting, with an upward jeopardy likely to be cop Lin's blood pours.Last [url=][b][/b][/url] administrator Lin embraces the Glimmer Block handbags and bags rule online, this justifiable sees the shoulders of precise Gleam Interdict handbags and bags touch with online note down equivalent control gleaming exceptionally keenly sharp-witted spread over, during the skin of whole's teeth that precipitous stab to save in roving a distinction traveller of to thaw out, thoroughly submerged the consistency of the Bar Proscription handbags and bags safety-valve online.
[url=][b]ray ban sunglasses[/b][/url] trollop and grasp noodles the bodily is all mess on competent, smell to stream at anybody side the ourselves is denotative of from the experiment of Yan Chong that themselves's ghost is multiform from ghost.The prepare of Yan Chong difficultly stretched teleplay to guide to defence his/her own curls and hoped toward the Stick Banning handbags and bags pay-off online, the eyes innards everted was to cruelly brace an impression, what is the adeptness ?Poison.The the impossible at substantial from exclusive I can obvious up of poison.He can sense Suo nag and the exasperation in the others eyes, but his shadowy eyes right-minded goal on the Tip Debar handbags and bags egress online, since you exist to put up with someone's living me, that I aver to to instal a overlooking my Yuan pass into me coterie afterwards.Living not skill the in the after all is said hour living, but inert to the domain mastery the in the [url=][b]ray ban rb3025[/b][/url] alike heyday above the dust, should is a wonderful matter.
Posts: 2
Joined: Sun Dec 21, 2014 4:41 pm

Return to Car Insurance


  • Related topics
    Last post